Australia‘s cricket selectors are grappling with a significant decision regarding the inclusion of teenage sensation Sam Konstas in the upcoming five-Test series against India. The debate centres around whether the 19-year-old is ready for the pressures of international cricket or if his debut should be delayed to protect his budding career.
The Debate: Is Sam Konstas ready?
Former Test opener Chris Rogers has raised concerns about the timing of Konstas’ potential debut. He believes that thrusting the young batsman into such a high-stakes series could be detrimental to his development. Drawing on his experience of playing in long, gruelling Test series, Rogers suggests that India’s relentless approach could expose and damage the teenager’s confidence.
“I know there’s a lot of talk about Konstas,” Rogers told SEN Radio. “I would just ask the question is he going to help win us this series, and if he’s not, if we don’t think he’s going to make that much of a difference, I would just leave it for this summer just because going and facing India could set you back a little bit.”
Rogers believes that while Konstas has a bright future ahead, a “softer landing” would be a wiser choice. “There’s no rush, he’s only 19. There’s going to be a big future for him… I’d be looking for someone a little bit more established at the moment, and then in the future say we can look at something different.”
If You’re Good Enough, You’re Old Enough?
On the other hand, current Test paceman Josh Hazlewood holds a contrasting view. Drawing from his own experience of making his debut at the age of 19, Hazlewood argues that Konstas’ age should not be a barrier. Having bowled to the young batsman in the nets, Hazlewood is confident in Konstas’ ability to handle the pressures of Test cricket.
“I don’t think anyone’s too young,” Hazlewood said. “A lot of the guys around here have played international cricket at quite a young age in different formats. I think for Test cricket if you need to throw him in there, people play at a young age from time to time… I’m sure he’ll work it out if he gets thrown in there.”
Hazlewood, who debuted as a teenager alongside other young stars like Pat Cummins and Mitchell Starc, is a firm believer in giving talented youngsters a chance, regardless of their age.
Selection Battle: Harris, McSweeney, and Konstas
The decision regarding Konstas’ inclusion will be influenced by the upcoming Australia A match against India A in Mackay, where he, Marcus Harris, and Nathan McSweeney will compete for two available batting spots in the 13-man Test squad. Selection chair George Bailey and his panel will have the final say on whether the teenage sensation gets his Test debut in Perth.
Rogers, now the coach of Victoria, is backing Harris, a seasoned 32-year-old with 14 Test matches under his belt, to secure a spot. “He’s moving as well as I’ve seen him,” Rogers said. Harris recently scored a century in the opening round of domestic cricket and performed well despite unfortunate dismissals. “If you look at this game, he got caught down the leg side twice off Mitchell Starc. That can happen… I think he’s batting really well.”
Challenge of Facing India
Regardless of who gets selected, the challenge of facing India is immense. Hazlewood does not believe that India’s recent dramatic collapse against New Zealand, where they were bowled out for 46, will affect their confidence. “I don’t think so, they’re a pretty resilient group,” he said. “They don’t sit and think about it too long, they get on with business… Dangerous team.”
As the Australia selectors weigh the risks and rewards, the decision on Sam Konstas’ debut will not only affect the upcoming series but could also shape the future of one of the country’s most promising young talents.
Editor's Pick
Top Stories
